Isiphandla Controversy Grips PSL – Referee gives player "red card" for wearing an isiphandla

Controversy Erupts in PSL Over Traditional Bracelet Isiphandla

Confusion and controversy have erupted in the Premier Soccer League (PSL) regarding isiphandla, a traditional bracelet crafted from the skin of a ceremonial goat. The issue came to a head when Sekhukhune United’s Thabang Monare was ordered off the pitch by referee Cedric Muvhali for wearing the wristband during a match against AmaZulu. This decision has sparked outrage among traditionalists, who feel that Muvhali overstepped his authority, despite the fact he was enforcing FIFA regulations that prohibit any form of jewellery and wristwear in football matches.

Monare’s ejection occurred just 12 minutes into the game, which ended in a 1-1 draw. Following the incident, Monare took to social media to express his frustration, highlighting the inconsistency in the enforcement of rules regarding isiphandla. In a previous match, he had been allowed to play while wearing the same band during Babina Noko’s 2-0 victory over Durban City, where he even scored.

Renowned cultural expert VVO Mkhize was among those who condemned Muvhali’s actions, stating, “That referee was wrong; he undermined our culture and tradition.” Mkhize explained the significance of isiphandla, saying, “Isiphandla is a sign of showing respect to the ancestors after doing a certain ceremony. In most cases, people wear isiphandla specifically because of their ancestors’ instructions. And to take it off, you need to slaughter a white chicken after a few months, notifying them that now you’re taking it off.”

He emphasised that wearing isiphandla is deeply rooted in cultural practices and that it should not be removed without proper rituals. “You can’t be told by anyone to take it off because that would put your life in danger. Your ancestors can get angry,” he added. While some wear isiphandla for cultural reasons, others do so simply because they like it. Regardless, the removal of the bracelet still requires a ceremonial process.

The controversy has highlighted inconsistencies in how the rules are applied within the league. Other players, such as Kaizer Chiefs’ Sibongiseni “OX” Mthethwa and Khulumani Ndamane of TS Galaxy, have worn isiphandla during matches without issue. This inconsistency raises questions about the enforcement of regulations and the understanding of cultural practices among referees.

It is not the first time a PSL referee has asked players to remove their isiphandla. In 2019, referee Jelly Chavani instructed Golden Arrows players Siyabonga Dube and Sibusiso Sibeko to take off their bracelets, which they did reluctantly.

Safa head of referees Abdul Ebrahim declined to comment on the matter, directing inquiries to the PSL. He confirmed that a letter had been sent to the league to explore potential solutions to the ongoing issue. PSL acting CEO Mato Madlala promised to discuss the situation with Ebrahim but had not provided any updates at the time of going to print.

Monare expressed a desire to speak on the matter but requested that Sekhukhune United grant him permission. However, the club’s marketing manager, Tebogo Mapinga, declined to comment further on the situation.

Interestingly, the debate over isiphandla is not limited to football. International cricketer Lungi Ngidi openly represents the Proteas with his isiphandla clearly visible, raising questions about the difference in how various sports organisations handle cultural expressions.

As the PSL navigates this complex issue, the need for greater understanding and respect for cultural practices within the sporting community has become increasingly evident. The incident with Monare serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between adhering to international regulations and respecting the rich traditions of South Africa. With discussions ongoing, fans and players alike are keen to see how the league will address these challenges moving forward.