Johannesburg, South Africa – In a move that has left many South Africans disheartened, the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) has been ordered to return a fleet of high-end supercars linked to Hangwani Morgan Maumela, the man accused of being a central figure in the colossal R2.3 billion looting of Tembisa Hospital. The decision, handed down by the Special Tribunal, represents a significant procedural setback for the state's anti-corruption efforts and raises urgent questions about the justice system's ability to hold the powerful to account.
The vehicles—two Aston Martins, two Ferraris, and a Rolls-Royce—were seized from a Mpumalanga dealership, Omar's Motor Den, during dramatic raids last year. Those raids, which also targeted Maumela’s lavish Sandton home where three Lamborghinis were confiscated, were seen as a rare moment of accountability. For a public weary of corruption, the images of these seized assets were a potent symbol that justice was finally catching up with those who plunder state coffers. Now, that symbol has been tarnished.
The tribunal's ruling hinged on a legal technicality. Former Special Tribunal president, Judge Margaret Victor, found that the SIU had failed to disclose key information when it first obtained the preservation order to seize the vehicles. While the cars are to be returned to the dealership, it is not an outright victory for Maumela. The order is conditional: Omar's Motor Den must provide financial security equal to the market value of each car, ensuring the assets remain under the control of a curator until the main legal case is finalised.
Despite this condition, the ruling is a bitter pill to swallow. It showcases how well-funded legal teams, likely financed by the very proceeds of crime, can exploit procedural missteps to outmanoeuvre state investigators. For many, it feels like a victory for the "tender kingpin," a man who remains free while the hospital he allegedly looted continues to suffer.
The Ghost of Babita Deokaran and the R2.3 Billion Heist
This case does not exist in a vacuum. It is inextricably linked to the ultimate sacrifice of whistle-blower Babita Deokaran. A senior official in the Gauteng Department of Health, Deokaran was brutally assassinated in August 2021 after she flagged hundreds of millions of rands in suspicious payments from Tembisa Hospital. In a chilling WhatsApp message to her boss shortly before her death, she wrote, "…I am just worried that the guys in Tembisa are going to realise we are not releasing their payments and know that we on to something. Our lives could be in danger."
Her murder blew the lid off a sophisticated and deeply entrenched network of corruption. The SIU's subsequent investigation uncovered what it described as three coordinated syndicates responsible for looting over R2 billion from the hospital. The scheme was staggering in its scale and simplicity: thousands of small, overpriced contracts were awarded to a web of shell companies, many controlled by the same individuals, to bypass normal procurement oversight.
Hangwani Maumela sits at the heart of this web. The SIU has traced 41 companies linked to him, which allegedly secured R820 million in fraudulent contracts between 2018 and 2023 for goods the hospital either did not need or purchased at grossly inflated prices. Investigators believe Maumela used family members and proxies to hide his assets, including at least 26 luxury vehicles worth an estimated R207 million.
The human cost of this looting is immeasurable. While billions were being siphoned off to fund lavish lifestyles, Tembisa Hospital was reportedly operating with less than half its required staff, facing chronic shortages of beds and resources, and discharging severely ill patients prematurely. The money stolen was not just a number on a balance sheet; it represented lives that could have been saved, care that could have been given, and a public health system that was bled dry.
A System of Impunity: "All Bark and No Bite"
The failure to prosecute Maumela and the recent return of his assets are a betrayal of Babita Deokaran's legacy. Her family, and the public, are still waiting for the masterminds behind her murder and the looting to face justice, even as the hired gunmen serve their sentences. This case highlights a frustrating reality in South Africa's fight against corruption: the system often appears to be "all bark and no bite," especially when dealing with the politically connected.
Maumela's alleged connections have been a subject of public debate. He was reported to be a nephew of President Cyril Ramaphosa through a previous marriage, a claim the President has publicly distanced himself from. In 2022, when asked about their relationship, President Ramaphosa stated, "I did not know him, because I had never encountered him, I had never seen him." He later clarified that 47 years ago he had married Maumela's aunt, but they had divorced 43 years ago.
Regardless of political ties, the pattern of impunity is clear. Maumela is reportedly bidding for a new R1 billion food tender, demonstrating a chilling audacity. The very individuals accused of grand-scale theft from the state are often the first in line for new government contracts, a cycle that perpetuates corruption and erodes public trust. The Democratic Alliance has even criticised the President's office for allegedly refusing to expand the SIU's investigation into Maumela's dealings in other provinces, despite evidence of his attempts to secure tenders in the North West.
The SIU, for its part, remains resolute. Spokesperson Kaizer Kganyago insists the tribunal's ruling is not a fatal blow to their case. He stated that the SIU believes the dealership, Omar's Motor Den, is acting as a "proxy for Maumela and others."
"We didn't just wake up and go to this dealership; we were following the sale of these cars and where the money went at Thembisa Hospital, and it ended up with them," Kganyago explained. He emphasised that the core purpose of the preservation order—to secure the value of the assets for eventual recovery—remains intact due to the financial security requirement.
The Returned Fleet: A Catalogue of Corruption
The list of vehicles ordered to be returned serves as a stark, visual reminder of the wealth accumulated through the alleged looting of a public hospital:
* **Two Aston Martin** supercars (2023 models)
* **One Ferrari 812** (2021 model)
* **One Ferrari 488 GTB** (2018 model)
* **One Rolls-Royce** (2023 model)
These cars, along with the Lamborghinis and other assets seized, represent the proceeds of a crime against the people of South Africa. Their return, even conditionally, is a public relations victory for the accused and a demoralising event for citizens who yearn for accountability. It emboldens the corrupt and sends a dangerous message that the justice system can be navigated and stalled, provided one has deep enough pockets. The fight for Tembisa Hospital, and for the soul of South Africa's anti-corruption efforts, is far from over. The question that remains is whether the state has the will and the competence to see it through to the end.
Follow Us on Twitter
